Showing posts with label trip advisor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label trip advisor. Show all posts

Monday, 26 June 2017

Hotels du Tour 2017

Last year it seemed that the big teams at the Tour de France – the likes of Sky and BMC – were getting a good deal. Perhaps stung by the criticism levelled at them in 2015, not only did ASO provide better quality hotels, they continued to match big budget teams with big budget hotels.

But what are things like this year? Who can remember a tweet or complaint from a rider about their accommodation this year? Has hotel quality improved? Or maybe riders been silenced by their teams keen to stay on the right side of race organisers?

Nevertheless, previous years have shown variations in the quality of hotels between teams. For 2017, the question is have ASO taken the opportunity to shuffle the hotel options around – give more questionable quality hotels to the big teams, and reward those who’ve had a bad deal in previous years?

Well, it looks like they might have – there’s a different feel to the hotel distribution this year.  

Lets look at the data for 2017.

Materials and Methods

As before, Ive used the Roadbook for the Tour de France to identify the hotels each team gets to stay in, and then looked them up on TripAdvisor to get levels of satisfaction. TripAdvisor uses a 5 point scale to assess customer satisfaction (from Excellent to Terrible): Ive combined the top 2 categories to calculate satisfaction. Sometimes hotels have lots of reviews, others not so many. Reviewers in expensive hotels may be more critical – who knows? Either way, the analysis is not adjusting for anything like that.


Results

2017 Hotel Quality

The first thing to notice is that this year, the overall level of satisfaction for Hotels in the Tour has risen. Maybe ASO have been consulting TripAdvisor for their hotel selection? Maybe reviewers on TripAdvisor are getting more generous in their assessments? Or maybe hotels in France are just getting better?

In 2016 the total satisfaction score was 38583.65 – this year it had risen to 38787.39. So a small rise which translates into a daily satisfaction increase of around 0.4%.  In fact, this is the second year that satisfaction levels have risen – although last year’s increase was more substantial.

The 2017 GC

Back in 2016, Trek Segafredo ran out winners of the Hotels du Tour GC, followed by Bora, Orica, BMC and Sky.

This year, it's a completely different GC – the teams with the big favourites, the likes of Sky, BMC and Trek are nowhere. Winning the GC is Bahrain-Merida – surely sending Nibali into one of his strops given his decision to miss this years race. Lotto-Soudal finish 2nd, with Katusha rounding off the podium. FDJ are 4th, with Cannondale continuing to bounce back from their lack of World Tour results in 5th.

-->
But what a race too! Bahrain-Merida took the yellow jersey (hotel?) on stage 3 only to suffer a stage 6 fringale of catastrophic proportions, falling to 18th on GC. Down, but not out, it takes an eyebrow-raising revival to catapault them back into contention by just stage 9. Hotel doping? Maybe I need to start looking at Booking.com and Expedia too.




The Favourites

Given that last year’s GC was packed with teams containing the top GC riders, it was tempting to think that maybe there’s a correlation between performance and hotel quality.

Whilst correlation does not equal causation, at this stage Chris Froome may be looking around for a motorhome. Just as his form has been inconsistent, so are his hotels. In fact, Sky’s Tour never gets going – never getting above 15th on the GC and eventually finishing a lowly 20th.

Quintana (or Valverde) has little to smile about – Movistar finish 13th – with Contador’s Trek a little worse off in 15th.

If this was to be the year for Romain Bardet, then ASO haven’t exactly done AG2R any favours. Not suited to the early flat stages, they spend their time bouncing around the bottom of the GC with Sky, only to pull themselves away from the lanterne rouge once they get to the mountains and finish 11th . A prophecy perhaps?

Which leaves BMC and Richie Porte. Demonstrating he’s escaped from Froome’s shadow, BMC never really threaten the GC but still finish the Tour in 6th place – and are the only big team that get close to their position from 2016.



The Key Changes: 2017 - 2016

So if there has been a changing of the guard, who has fared best and worst?

No doubt the biggest decline is in Team Sky, falling 16 places on GC in 2017. Quick Step / Etixx fell 12 places and Trek 14.

Shooting up (the charts) are last  year’s lanterne rouge chasers Lampre. Changing their name to Bahrain-Merida has seen their GC position rise 19 places. Getting Alpecin on as co-sponsors as also helped Katusha: its not just their hair that’s benefitted, but their GC position has risen 11 places.

But pity poor old Giant Alpecin/Team Sunweb. Last on the GC in 2016, they are last again in 2017 (not forgetting 17th in 2015). They are nothing if not consistent. But no wonder Tom Dumoulin chose to ride the Giro.



The Best and the Worst Hotels

If you’re looking for somewhere to stay in France, then you could do a lot worse than the Inter Hotel Vamcel – this year’s highest scoring hotel (97.2% satisfaction). Orica get to stay here on stage 11. But pity Team Astana who get to ‘enjoy’ the luxury of the 33.6% rated Campanile, Bergerac. Not just for 1 night, though – but three! As they say for every Chateau there’s a Campanile – and for stages 9-10 (including the rest day) its Wanty Groupe Gobert that get to stay in the Chateau des Vigiers at Monestier (87.7% satisfaction). Perhaps a little surprising was to see the Novotel in Dijon amongst the lowest scoring hotels (stage 7 for Orica and Direct Energie). I last stayed there in the early 80’s and it was alright, but perhaps it’s changed a bit since...

The Best and the Worst Stages

The best hotels seem to be found at the start, middle and end of the race - some psychology there from ASO perhaps? However, the gap between the best and the worst hotels also happens at the end of the first week of racing, although the second week is not too bad.








Conclusion

They say in cycling that the Tour is the Tour, but also that what goes around comes around. Looking at these results you might agree. There’s definitely been a reshuffling of the pack. Last year’s winners have fallen from grace, whilst others have risen from the depths. Maybe Sky’s experience will revive talk of motorhomes? And if ASO have some kind of hotel rotation policy, then maybe it’s only visible over a longer time period. Or maybe ASO’s hotel algorithm is just chance: some teams like Team Sunweb will be wondering what they’ve got to do to get decent hotels.

Tuesday, 30 June 2015

Hotel Quality in the 2015 Tour de France

Who needs a motorhome?

Team Sky’s motorhome, unveiled at the Giro d’Italia in May 2015, was supposed to provide the best recovery environment for their team leader – Richie Porte. No more would he be subject to the vagaries of a different hotel everyday with their dodgy beds, mouldy tiles and iffy wifi. Regular, standardised comfort was the name of the game. That the quality of hotels was seen as a problem by riders was magnified when the UCI banned the use of motorhomes. Other riders took to twitter posting pictures of the bizarre dormitories and sleeping arrangements they’d had to put up with.
Stage race organisers say they try to equalize the quality of accommodation between teams. When it comes to the Tour de France, organisers ASO say they visit each hotel they use, rate them on a scale of 1-5, and then randomly distribute the hotels so that everyone gets a fair share of the good, the bad and the ugly.

The question is: how accurate are ASO, or do some teams still have an advantage? To put it another way: were Team Sky onto something when they bought their RV?


The Wisdom of the Crowd (Peloton?)

Dave Brailsford returned from a trip to Silicon Valley raving about how ‘big data’ and ‘the wisdom of the crowds’ would offer the next crucial performance breakthroughs in cycling. So what better way of analyzing hotel quality than using online hotel reviews?! There are some problems with using hotel reviews from a site like Trip Advisor (for example, see this paper). But no doubt Brailsford’s Silicon Valley chums told him about “Linus’s law”: ‘Given enough eyeballs, all bugs are shallow’. We'll just go with that.

Using Trip Advisor and the Tour de France Road Book, we identified all the hotels used during the 2015 Tour and their percentage of positive reviews – that's ‘excellent’ and ‘very good’ ratings combined. Out of the 184 hotels used by the Tour, 181 were in Trip Advisor. That includes the hotels used for the rest days and the pre-tour presentation. For those hotels, that amounts to a total of 26737 reviews, with a median of just over 100 but with a lot of variation (those in the large cities tend to get more reviews than those in the sticks).

For the three hotels who had 'missed tests' - where they weren't available - we gave them the lowest value for that stage – a bit like being relegated to the back of the peloton. Some of them might have a good excuse, however. One of the hotels without any reviews appears to be caught up in some sort of dispute with the local mayor, which might explain the absence of reviews on Trip Advisor. By using that hotel, ASO seem to be meddling in politics - plus ça change...

Stage Winning Hotels

So, what are the hotels like at this year’s Tour? Upsetting for ASO, perhaps, the stages with the best average hotel satisfaction come on the first two days when the race is in Holland. The worst stage is the last when all teams get to stay in the Hyatt Regency Paris Etoile, which is “run down, shabby and old” according to one Trip Advisor reviewer. Stage winning hotels and those finishing in the autobus are shown below. You can see the podium for each day here.


A couple of hotels have a 100% satisfaction score. Pas normal, peut-etre? Stage 9 has the Inter Hotel Vamcel, Lescar which Orica are lucky enough to stay in. Their bus driver should be careful, though: one reviewer commented that space for parking was limited. Another 100% hotel is on Stage 15 - Hotel Sous les Pins in which Team Giant get to rest their legs in. The last - Hotel Les Airelles in La Toussuire - is on stages 18/19, in which FDJ and BMC get to stay in. Mind you, that one only has 3 reviews - sort of equivalent to an incomplete biological passport.

Stage 14 also has some good hotels: the Kyriad la Garde, Albaret Sainte Marie which Astana and Europcar get to stay in has a 98% satisfaction rate. One previous guest commented that: “the staff were incredibly helpful, nothing was too much trouble. The room was very clean and neat as was the bathroom and the bed was so comfy!”. But stage 14 also has some of the worst: Le Panoramic Gararit in Anglards de Saint Flour is described as “a sad and depressing fly infected excuse for a hotel” by one past guest. Tour de France debutants MTN-Qhubeka have the misfortune of staying there. The worst of the entire Tour is the Hotel des Messageries in Saint Flour. With just a 9% satisfaction rating, one Trip Advisor reviewer describes it as a 'dirty, ugly nightmare'. Good job cycling teams have their own chefs these days, otherwise it'd probably be just bread and water.

Its worth pointing out that teams often get to stay in the same hotel for several nights, and this often occurs at crucial points in the race. For the Pyrenean stages, Team Sky gets to stay in one of the best hotels of the race (with 93% satisfaction) for 4 consecutive nights. By contrast, their GC rivals Movistar and Tinkoff-Saxo get to stay in a hotel with just a 49% satisfaction level. Maybe Sky’s motorhome wasn't needed after-all?




The General Classification

Despite ASO’s insistence, there are substantial variations in hotel quality between teams. Top of hotel GC is Lotto-Jumbo, with Lampre-Merida as the hotel laterne rouge. Maybe ASO should think about using Trip Advisor to divvy up the hotels - their classification doesn't seem to be working.

Of the big 4 GC teams, highest placed is Astana in 3rd overall. Team Sky slot into fourth place. Of the remaining GC contenders, Nairo Quintana’s Movistar is in 21st place, and Alberto Contador’s Tinkoff-Saxo in 14th place.

Team
Total Satisfaction Score
Final GC Position
Satisfaction Daily Average
Lotto-Jumbo
1905.48
1
79.395
BMC
1790.68
2
74.61
Astana
1746.33
3
72.76
Sky
1736.9
4
72.37
Orica
1735.75
5
72.32
IAM ***
1719.25
6
71.64
FDJ
1715.6
7
71.48
MTN
1679.81
8
69.99
Lotto-Soudal *
1678.37
9
69.93
Bora
1664.89
10
69.37
Etixx
1664.88
11
69.37
AG2R
1663.72
12
69.32
Cannondale
1660.18
13
69.17
Tinkoff
1657.21
14
69.05
Bretagne *
1645.91
15
68.58
Cofidis
1627.28
16
67.80
Giant
1622.14
17
67.59
Europcar
1610.43
18
67.10
Katusha **
1606.1
19
66.92
Trek
1554.24
20
64.76
Movistar ***
1501.71
21
62.57
Lampre ***
1365.3
22
56.89

* Missing reviews on 4 stages –lowest hotel satisfaction score for the stages used
** Missing review on 1 stage –lowest hotel satisfaction score for the stage used
*** Missing review on 2 stages –lowest hotel satisfaction score for the stages used


Just like the race itself, these GC positions change – although Lotto-Jumbo nearly pull off a Merckxian like start to finish hold on the hotel yellow jersey. Sky’s 4th place on GC belies their poor start in the flatlands and cobbles, only coming on strong when the race hits the high mountains. An omen perhaps for Chris Froome?





The Finish Line

Despite what ASO say, there are substantial differences in hotel quality between Tour teams. Hotel quality does not even out over the length of the Tour. Maybe ASO’s hotel reviewers are more attuned to pro-cyclists’ demands than Trip Advisor’s reviewers. But the most common complaints in Trip Advisor are about poor quality bedrooms, cleanliness and lack of air conditioning – the same concerns that pro-cyclists have.

Team Sky may have been on to something with their motorhome, but ironically it would have served the needs of some of the riders in the poorer teams in the peloton than Chris Froome.



Notes

Data were extracted from Trip Advisor 22-26 June. Trip Advisor reviews are constantly updated – hotel satisfaction levels change over time. Don't blame me if they change when you look.